English Tea Shop Christmas Cake Tea Review

English Tea Shop Christmas Cake Tea Review

I usually have trifle after Christmas dinner. Is that weird? I often find that Christmas cake or Christmas pudding is just far too filling after I’ve stuffed myself with turkey and pigs in blankets.

That’s why this tea caught my eye. The idea of having a lovely spiced Christmas cake without getting full up is revolutionary. Unfortunately, I didn’t get to brew this tea on Christmas day, but I’ll be sure to save a teabag or two for next Christmas!

This is the full review of English Tea Shop Christmas Cake Tea, one of 12 teas in the ETS Christmas Tea Collection that you can buy all year round (yay).

ETS Christmas Cake Tea at a Glance

Izzy's Rating
  • Blend: Black tea with orange, apple, peach, cinnamon, ginger and vanilla
  • Flavour: Light smooth, honeyed malt and spices with notes of peach

They weren’t messing around when they named this tea. The aroma is exactly like Christmas cake fresh from the oven, yet the flavour is delightfully smooth and refreshing with subtle hints of cakey goodness.

ets christmas cake tea

Full Review – Christmas Cake Black Tea

Izzy's Rating
  • Type: Tagged paper tea bag
  • Tea: Black tea
  • Additives: Orange peel, apple pieces, cocoa, natural flavouring, cinnamon, ginger, vanilla pods
  • Flavour Notes: Light, smooth, sweet honey, malt, peaches, sultanas
  • Aroma: Disaronno (Italian almond liqueur), sultanas, Christmas pudding, malt, sticky toffee pudding
  • Milk or Lemon: Sweetener if desired
  • Where to Buy: Amazon (part of a gift set)

I was incredibly impressed with the oomph of the teabag! It has a very strong aroma that instantly reminds you of Christmas cake. Unlike some flavoured teas, you could do a blind sniff test with this one and immediately recognise what it was supposed to be. Notes of rich Disaronno almonds, malty black tea and sticky toffee pudding melt together to create a fruity, decadent Christmas cake aroma.

It brews into a muddy brown cake colour, but you’ll be far too excited to sip it to care that the colour is a little unappetising.

And when you do finally take a sip, there will be a moment of silence…

… because the flavour doesn’t live up to the aroma. Don’t get me wrong, it’s very pleasant. Light smooth notes of honey and malt twirl around with peaches and sultanas. But it’s not rich, thick and stodgy like a true Christmas cake. The black tea is very light indeed.

I finished the cup because it was pleasant to drink, but I just wish it was true to the initial aroma.

christmas tea collection

How to Brew English Tea Shop Organic Christmas Cake Tea

I brewed for 4 minutes, took a sip, then brewed for a further minute. 5 minutes of brewing in 100°C water did the trick for me, as I usually enjoy my teas quite light.

ETS recommends serving with lemon and/or a sweetener of your choice. I can’t see how lemon would be a good idea, but a generous teaspoon of honey would certainly be in the Christmas spirit.

This makes a nice dessert tea after a very heavy meal, but perhaps with a few biscuits as it’s nowhere near as rich and satisfying as true Christmas cake.

Why the English Tea Shop Christmas Tea Collection?

English Tea Shop is possibly the best tea brand around for Christmas teas. I’ve got the red bauble box of teas to share, which I’m keeping all to myself, naturally. This was the first tea I laid my eyes on… and the quality is not so good.

First, each teabag is wrapped individually in clear plastic. Why!? This is such a waste of plastic packaging and it isn’t needed. With only 5 teabags per mini box, it’s not like the tea will be stored in your cupboard for months at a time. They could have been wrapped together in one piece of plastic and that would have sufficed.

Furthermore, even though the tea is pure Ceylon tea, packaged in Sri Lanka where it was harvested, it is not good quality. The flecks are tiny and you can see that there’s added natural flavouring as well.

The only positive aspect to highlight is that this tea is certified organic by the Soil Association.


I do recommend this tea… as part of the collection. It’s a fantastic idea that hasn’t been executed as well as I’d like. Nonetheless, it’s very pleasant to sip and will add to your Christmas cheer. Make sure you buy the collection box using the button below to get enough tea to share with friends and family too.

christmas themed teabags

Tea Recommendation

If you’re feeling super Christmassy, I highly recommend you check out my review of Whittard Christmas Tea! This is another Christmas tea with more of a spiced chai vibe, rather than a sweet and malty vibe. The 2 teas work so well together and are great for the festive season.

Isobel Moore

Isobel Moore is a quiet, quirky and creative “human bean” whose favourite pastime is curling up with a cuppa and a good book.

Over the past 5 years, her tea reviews at Immortal Wordsmith have helped thousands of readers choose vibrant tea blends and single origin selections from fine, organic, and responsible tea companies.

As a professional content writer with a qualification in digital marketing, Isobel has worked with market-leading tea brands around the globe to develop their content marketing campaigns and gain exposure. Her professional portfolio can be found on Upwork.

Besides a deep-rooted passion for tea, Isobel writes on topics ranging from food and travel to wellness and literature.

Favourite Quote: “Manuscripts don’t burn” – Mikhail Bulgakov

Leave a Reply